Review: Gentle Monster


Official Synopsis:
Lucy, (Lea Seydoux) a renowned pianist relocates with her family to the countryside, where she uncovers a life-shattering truth about her husband, Philip (Laurence Rupp) that forces her to confront the complexities of love, trust, and deception.

Writer/Director Marie Kreutzer started a version of this screenplay before she filmed her previous feature Corsage in 2022. However while making that film, she (like Lucy in this film) was faced with the hard truth that her lead actor Florian Teichtmeister had been arrested for possession of child pornography. That incident is what shapes Gentle Monster. 

Because Kreutzer lived a version of this story, albeit a much less dramatic one as it was her employee and not her spouse, everything that happens in the first half of this movie feels very sincere. Lucy remarks at one point to another character that there's no light switch for love. You can find out something bad about another person, and it's not like all your feelings just disappear, even if you want them too. Lucy's struggle with finding out her husband committed such a disgusting crime, to the uncertainty on whether he ever harmed their son, to not wanting to tell anyone about it is very compelling She also incorporates a few flashbacks to show how Philip was hiding this, but without the additional context we have as the viewer, they look so normal. And I think that was a smart choice to show how monsters hide in plain sight light that. Parts of this film are so unsettling to watch, though thankfully no abuse is ever shown.

I wish Kreutzer would've sat with this idea longer, because while the film starts off strong, I felt like she didn't know what to do with it after Philip is arrested. There is a side plot with the lead police officer on the case, Elsa (Jella Haase) that feels like it had been written, then re-written more than once. It doesn't blend well with Lucy's story and I think there are ways we could've followed these two women. Maybe if we had focused more on Elsa's work rather than her home life, which is meant to draw a comparison with Lucy. 

Lea Seydoux is giving an amazing performance in this and is THE reason to watch, but I ended up feeling very let down by this. A movie with this heavy of a subject matter should have a better conclusion, instead it just sort of meanders around. 

Grade: C+

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Random Ramblings: The Radio Flyer Conundrum

Please join me in my Favorite Movie Titles Blogathon!

Review: Lilies Not For Me