White Swan/Black Swan Blogathon


The wonderful Sati over at Cinematic Corner has come up with a great idea for a blogathon. She asks us to pick characters to showcase their "white swan/black swan" So basically, to show how they have wildy contrasting traits that they show to some, and now others. Here are the rules:

1. Choose max 3 characters to write about.
2. You can also feature characters from TV series.
3. We are not looking for doppelgangers - we are looking for one person with two sides. For example in Black Swan you can write about Nina and her alter ego but not about Lily and Nina, which are two different people. You can write about Gollum/Smeagol but you cannot write about Bette and Dot - the Siamese twins from AHS: Freakshow - because technically they are two different people.
4. Write about why you chose the character 

5. Provide a theory on what causes the two different sides and what are the signs and contradictions between the two, for example you can write about things like that:

*Spoiler alerts*

Walter White of Breaking Bad

Let's start with the obvious. Walter White and his alter ego "Heisenberg."


White Swan: Kind, family man, somewhat of a push over, insecure.



Black Swan: Over confident, murderer, liar, schemer.

The difference between Walt and Heisenberg is for obvious reasons like I pointed out. He's a secret drug dealer. But I chose Walt because I find him to be one of the most fascinating characters I've ever watched. It was almost impossible not to root for him at times. Starting out as the teacher who had a part time job at a car wash, and had to clean his cocky student's car to becoming "the one who knocks" was brilliant. The lines between the two eventually began to blur, but we were constantly reminded that even though Walt is in the big times now, we still knew where he came from.

In the final episode, Walt says it himself. "I did it for me. I liked it. I was good at it. I was really...I was alive."

Angela Hayes of American Beauty


White Swan: Low self esteem, a virgin, seemingly needs love and structure.


Black Swan: Confident, greatly exaggerates things, sexually experienced. 

In Angela's case, it's the black swan we see the most of. She tells the world she's had all the experiences, yet she's hiding behind false confidence and tells people things that she thinks they want to here. There's an interesting parallel between Angela and her friend Jane in the film. Jane gradually starts wearing less make up as her character begins to come into her own, and Angela gradually wears more and people start to see through her facade. I think what it boils down to is Angela is someone that craves attention because she probably isn't getting much of it at home. She's disappointed her modeling career isn't taking off, so she tries to make herself sound bigger than she is. She's in need of a good friend or a steady parent to learn from. I chose Angela because American Beauty is my favorite movie and I find each and
every character endlessly interesting. 

14 comments:

  1. Angela is SUCH a good choice because, as you say, it’s usually the white swan that we see from these characters. But she sports her black swan proudly, which makes the reveal of her white swan so shocking. Great pick!

    Also, since American Beauty is your favorite movie, I think you’ll appreciate this. Last month I was at a loft party and my friend introduced me to a bunch of her friends. Half hour later I accidentally reintroduced myself to one of them.

    Her: “Actually we met briefly earlier.”
    Me: “Oh shit, I’m so sorry.”
    Her: “No that’s okay, I wouldn’t remember me either.”
    Me: “Honey, don’t be weird.”

    And then we talked for two hours haha. Still talking today actually!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. omg I love you. LOL

      I feel like I pick American Beauty for SO many blogathons, but I couldn't stop thinking of Angela when putting this together.

      Delete
  2. Love the Walter White and Heisenberg pick, the character is so watchable and the main reason I was so addicted to Breaking Bad. Great post :-) - Jen

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes! I love Breaking Bad. Easily the best TV Show I've ever seen.

      Delete
  3. Thanks so much for participating and I love your choices! Walter is a great pick but I really love Angela since it's such a good choice also to show how American Beauty plays with expectations and in the end it's Angela who is kinda an ordinary, cliche loser and Thora Birch's character is the one who triumphs because she is an outsider.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for hosting! :) This was fun, and one that took a lot of thought. (for me anyways)

      Delete
  4. Love the Angela choice! That's such a brilliant example (I love that character/performance so much). I haven't seen Breaking Bad yet :-(

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You NEED to watch Breaking Bad. It's so good!

      And thank you. :)

      Delete
  5. Oh, that is a good choice as while I have mixed feelings on American Beauty. Angela is a great character as she is someone that pretends to be something but is really just as fucked up as everyone else.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great picks! Choosing a character who chooses the black swan as her public persona is brilliant.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't seen Breaking Bad, but Angela is such an interesting choice. Great job!

    ReplyDelete

If you're reading this sentence you should probably leave a comment.